by No Comments

In a previous blog, Reconnect Rochester examined the most common crash in Monroe County involving bicyclists: a motorist failing to yield to a sidewalk-riding cyclist approaching from the motorist’s right at a red light, stop sign, or parking lot exit.

Because this crash is so common and there’s much confusion around the issue, it was worth a follow-up deep dive.

In New York State, as elsewhere, bicyclists have to follow (almost all of) the rules for drivers of motor vehicles **when traveling in the roadway**, an important distinction to make. This means bike riders have to ride on the right side with the flow of traffic when riding in the street.

But do bicyclists HAVE to travel in the road? No. Not here. As we’ve pointed out, Rochester and Monroe County generally allow bicyclists with regular pedal bikes (not e-bikes!) to ride on the sidewalk if they prefer. Obviously, cyclists tend to choose this option when the roadways are intimidating, when motorist speeds are too high, and/or when dedicated bike infrastructure is nonexistent.

When riding on sidewalks and trails, bike riders have to yield to everyone else: walkers, joggers, wheelchair users, dog-walkers, people pushing strollers, etc. i.e. No one has to get out of the cyclist’s way.

Click here to learn where sidewalk-riding is prohibited in Monroe County

As Vehicular Cycling guru John Forester points out, “Cyclists are unique because they are the only [roadway] users who have a choice: They can follow drivers’ rules when traveling on the roadway, or pedestrians’ rules if they travel on the sidewalk.” He contends sidewalk-riding is the cyclist’s “last resort when nothing else works.” John Forester was one of the most anti-sidewalk-riding cyclists that ever lived, and even he contends 1) Cyclists have the right to ride on the sidewalk (except where it’s prohibited) and 2) There’s times sidewalk-riding is advantageous.

Here is where the issue gets messy: Can bike riders only ride on the sidewalk on the right side of the road with the flow of traffic? We’d contend No. Bicyclists can ride in each direction on the sidewalk just as pedestrians can walk each way on the sidewalk. Besides, the farther out you get in Monroe County, the more likely it is that a road, if it’s fortunate to have a sidewalk at all, will have one only on one side.

Riding on the left sidewalk opens you up to the most common bicycle crash in Monroe County – but as we’ve already shown, that crash is the fault of the motorist for failing to yield. Though it’s not the bicyclist’s fault, caution should certainly be exercised when riding on the left sidewalk.

It’s far safer, when riding on the sidewalk, to ride on the one on the right side of the road with the flow of traffic. Motorists are much more likely to look in your direction and yield before turning.

As Forester noted, and we strongly concur, riding on the left sidewalk should only be used for very short maneuvers when we can use it to our advantage.

Here are common Rochester scenarios where I’ll ride on the left sidewalk briefly…

Going northbound in the road on Wisconsin Street in North Winton Village, the traffic light at Merchants won’t detect me. Plus Merchants is always an uncomfortable tight squeeze and I’d have to make an immediate left turn onto Grand Ave anyway. I’ll typically use the left sidewalk on Merchants for one block to get to Grand. Totally logical. Nothing wrong with it. I yield to pedestrians and go on the grass briefly if necessary.

Going towards downtown in the mornings, I can cross Culver Rd on Grand Ave quickly if traffic isn’t too busy. But if it’s rush hour and breaks in traffic are seldom, I’ll ride on the left sidewalk for one block to Garson, where I can press the beg button and use the traffic light to cross. Then I’ll resume riding in the street.

From Red Wings games or High Falls, I use the bike boulevard network to get home. The traffic light at Ward St and Joseph Ave won’t detect me. And even if it did, it would take forever. I’ll use the left sidewalk for one block on Joseph, then resume riding in the street on Nassau.

As we’ve noted before, this is one of the ways cyclists can make a left turn in Rochester.

Here is what we’ve noticed, however, when analyzing crash reports: Law Enforcement every now and then presumes the cyclist isn’t allowed to ride on the left sidewalk. Sometimes they reprimand the cyclist for doing so or call it “illegal” in their report. In these instances, law enforcement is mistaken. In February 2026, we spoke to the Monroe County Chiefs of Police Association about this topic. But it’s apparent that what we said went in one ear and out the other, was dismissed, or just hasn’t filtered down to officers responding to collisions.

Here is some of what we emphasized at that presentation.

As § 1234 states, cyclists have to ride on the right side when traveling on roadways.

In New York State, as elsewhere, sidewalks are not considered part of the roadway (§ 140). It’s a little ambiguous, but it’s implicit that when riding on sidewalks outside the curb, the law treats bike riders as pedestrians. (It’s not uncommon for Police Officers to refer to sidewalk-riding cyclists involved in crashes as pedestrians in their reports). Bicyclists can ride in each direction on the sidewalk just as pedestrians can walk each way on the sidewalk. There’s nothing inherently illegal about riding on the left sidewalk. But many Police Officers don’t know this.

When Police Officers receive training for bike patrol, this is their textbook. As you can see, it backs up our contention.

We find the following example from California instructive. (NY and CA laws are very similar).

In a 1993 opinion, the California Attorney General stated that “to the extent that a vehicle must be driven on the right half of the roadway, a bicyclist riding on an adjacent sidewalk must travel in the same direction as the vehicular traffic.”

BUT in 2013, that opinion was overruled.

We’re confident the same opinion would be reached in New York State if it were held under similar scrutiny.

In sum…

  • Generally speaking, riding in the street, with the flow of traffic on the right side, is best practice and not as dangerous as many think.
  • Due to unsafe road conditions and lack of motorist accountability, we’ll concede there are times when the sidewalk is the safest place to ride. In Rochester and much of Monroe County, sidewalk-riding is allowed. (See here for where it isn’t).
  • It’s far safer, when riding on the sidewalk, to ride on the one on the right side of the road. You’re more visible and predictable on that side.
  • As we’ve outlined in our examples, we only recommend riding on the left sidewalk for brief maneuvers, exercising caution as you do so.
  • We’ve seen many instances of Law Enforcement in Monroe County not being aware that cyclists are allowed to ride on the left sidewalk. Efforts to refresh them on the rights of cyclists will have to be ongoing.
  • Motorists are supposed to come to a complete stop **before** they enter the sidewalk/crosswalk area. They can only encroach into it if they’ve ensured the way is clear in both directions and there’s no one entering that space they could collide with.
  • From a legal standpoint, it doesn’t matter if the cyclist crashes into the side of the car or if the front of the car strikes the cyclist as they ride by: Both are instances of the motorist failing to yield.
  • With the exception of “Don’t Walk” signals, it’s not the person using the sidewalk/crosswalk who is expected to yield.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *